Benchmarks: Citrix XenDesktop 2.1 vs VMware View 3.0

Posted by virtualization.info Staff   |   Tuesday, February 17th, 2009   |  

citrix logo

vmware logo

For the forth time in few days that benchmarks about Citrix and VMware desktop virtualization (VDI, presentation virtualization and application virtualization) solutions take the central stage.
Is it a sign that somebody is getting nervous?

The first (non-sponsored) analysis came out from two independent enterprise architects, Ruben Spruijt and Jeroen van de Kamp, which evaluated how XenServer, ESX and Hyper-V perform in VDI scenarios.

After an immediate reaction from VMware, a XenDesktop 2.1 Scalability Analysis popped up from Citrix (to be fair this document was released on Jan 12, days before the Spruijt/van de Kamp work, and further updated on Jan 27).

Then an independent performance comparison (committed by VMware) between Microsoft App-V, Symantec/Altiris SVS, VMware ThinApp and Citrix XenApp was released by the Exo Performance Network team.

The last episode of this saga come out last week from the Tolly Group.

The test lab realized an independent performance comparison (once again committed by VMware) between Citrix XenDesktop 2.1 Enterprise and VMware View 3.0 Premier.

As for any sponsored analysis the results are easy to guess:

The VMware View 3 VDI solution deployed more simply and more rapidly than Citrix XenDesktop 2.1. VMware provided more comprehensive, efficient image and storage management of virtual desktops. It provides end-users with a quality of experience on the LAN that matches or exceeds that offered by the Citrix solution.

Citrix promptly answers from the corporate blog, invalidating the analysis as it covers unrealistic scenarios and evaluates an old product (XenDesktop 3.0 was released just two weeks ago):

There’s a prominent sidebar that in the report that states that Citrix declined to participate in the testing – this is true, and I was the one that actually made that call and discussed it with Tolly Group. To their credit, Tolly Group did call us prior to beginning the testing and informed us of the project and shared the statement of work prepared for VMware. We asked some questions and provided some feedback about the testing methodology. I had serious concerns that the proposed tests did not reflect true customer use cases. For example, the user experience testing was only for a few productivity applications in a LAN environment – that was all that was planned, and it didn’t seem to realistic based on what we’ve seen in real customer environments. Tolly took note of our concerns and asked VMware as the sponsor of the paper whether they would alter their approach.  Later we learned that VMware (not surprisingly) had rejected our suggestions and was not open to changing the proposed tests. At that point, it was clear that it made no sense to participate because…



blog comments powered by Disqus


virtualization.info Newest articles
Will HP buy VMware from EMC?

September 17th, 2014

Last week the New York times published an article titled: “EMC explores selling stake in VMware“. While the news that EMC is exploring selling VMware is not new though. Paul…

Docker raises $40 million in series C funding

September 17th, 2014

After raising $15 million in Series B funding in January this year, Docker has announced that it has raised $40 million in Series C funding. Docker states that it will…

Release: VMware Mirage 5.1

September 17th, 2014

VMware has released version 5.1 of its centralized image management for Windows desktops: Mirage.
VMware Mirage is also part of the Horizon Suite, VMware’s end user computing suite that includes…

Release: Proxmox VE 3.3

September 16th, 2014

Proxmox Virtual Environment (VE) is an open source virtualization management solution that leverages KVM technologies.
Yesterday Proxmox Server Solutions GmbH announced the release of version 3.3 of its product that…

Convirture opens a UK based office to explore EMEA market

September 15th, 2014

Convirture the company, founded in 2006 that provides an open source management console to manage virtualization platforms,  announced to have opened a UK- based office which will help the company…

Release: VMware ThinApp 5.1

September 12th, 2014

VMware has released version 5.1 of its application virtualization product ThinApp. Version 5.1 is the follow up of version 5.0 which was released in November last year. The update provides…

Brian Stevens former Red Hat CTO joins Google as VP of Cloud Platforms

September 12th, 2014

Two weeks ago we were wondering about Brian Stevens, who resigned as Red Hat’s CTO, asking ourselves if this could be seen as a “tremendous opportunity” for both.
Red Hat…

HP Acquires Eucalyptus

September 12th, 2014

Yesterday HP announced to have reached a definitive agreement to acquire Eucalyptus, provider of an open source Cloud Solution competing with OpenStack, CloudStack and OpenNebula.
This acquisition will put…

Release: VMware ESXi and vCenter Server 5.5 Update 2

September 12th, 2014

This week VMware released version 5.5 Update 2 of two of its flagship products, ESXi and vCenter Server, updates that were announced at VMworld 2014 in San Francisco.
Among the…

Release: Red Hat Satellite 6

September 11th, 2014

Satellite is Red Hat’s server life-cycle management based on the community project Spacewalk, it basically provides provision, patch, configuration and subscription management across Red Hat’s ecosystem.
Yesterday the Raleigh company…

Release: Oracle VM VirtualBox 4.3.16

September 11th, 2014

Oracle has released a new version of its virtualization platform VM Virtualbox. Version 4.3.16 is considered a maintenance release which can be installed on top of version 4.3. The update…

Microsoft releases limited preview of Migration Accelerator for Azure

September 8th, 2014

Microsoft last week announced a limited preview of Migration Accelerator (MA) for Azure. MA can seamlessly migrate physical, VMware, Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Hyper-V workloads into Azure, automating discovery…

Amazon CFO will retire in summer 2015

September 5th, 2014

On September 3, Amazon announced that Chief Financial Officer Thomas Szkutak plans to retire in June 2015 after about 13 years in the business, beginning in October 2002, where he…

Release: VMware Fusion 7

September 3rd, 2014

Following the technology preview announced in May VMware has released version 7 of its desktop virtualization platform for OS X: Fusion.
This new release, that comes in the normal and…

 
Monthly Archive