Xen will never be part of Linux

Posted by virtualization.info Staff   |   Monday, May 12th, 2008   |  

Recently ZDNet published a skirmish of words between Ian Pratt, Xen founder and chief architect, and Benny Schnaider, CEO of Qumranet (supporting the development of KVM), about the destiny of Xen and the right to be called hypervisor of KVM.

While the debate itself is not too much interesting, one of the reactions that it provoked is much more.

Anthony Liguori, Software Engineer at Linux Technology Center, contributor for both Xen and KVM ( and of Debunking Blue Pill Myth fame), used his personal blog to provide some interesting perspectives of why KVM was preferred over Xen for the integration in the Linux kernel:

Xen is a hypervisor that is based on the Nemesis microkernel. Linux distributions ship Xen today and by default install a Linux guest (known as domain-0) and do their best to hide the fact that Xen is not a part of Linux. They’ve done a good job, most users won’t even notice that they are running an entirely different Operating System. The whole situation is somewhat absurd though. It’s like if the distributions shipped a NetBSD kernel automatically and switched to using it when you wanted to run a LAMP stack. We don’t ship a plethora of purpose-built kernels in a distribution. We ship one kernel and make sure that it works well for all users. That’s what makes a Linux distribution Linux. When you take away the Linux kernel, it’s not Linux any more.

When people talk about Xen not being merged into Linux, I don’t think they realize that Xen will *never* be merged into Linux. Xen will always be a separate, purpose-built kernel. There are patches to Linux that enable it to run well as a guest under Xen. These patches are likely to be merged in the future, but Xen will never been a part of the Linux kernel…


Labels:

blog comments powered by Disqus


virtualization.info Newest articles
Microsoft releases Azure Stack TP1

February 1st, 2016

During Ignite 2015, back in September, Microsoft announced Microsoft Azure Stack as the building block for its hybrid cloud strategy.
What Microsoft is saying with this move is that, despite…

Release: Ansible 2.0

January 14th, 2016

Ansible is an IT automation tool especially popular within the developers’ community, thanks to its simplicity and agentless nature.
Three months away from its acquisition by Red Hat the company announced…

Nutanix goes Public

December 23rd, 2015

Nutanix is a provider of converged infrastructure, basically a physical server containing both compute and storage driven by an Installed Hypervisor of choice, this server, called a node can…

Release: VMware vRealize Automation 7 and VMware vRealize Business Standard 7

December 23rd, 2015

Last week VMware finally completed the first major update of VMware vRealize Suite, its well known cloud management solution, releasing in GA both vRealize Automation 7 and vRealize Business Standard…

WhatMatrix.com goes Live

December 15th, 2015

virtualization.info has been following Virtualization Matrix since its early steps and we recently wrote about its crowdsourced-powered heir: WhatMatrix.
Today we are happy to report that its community, formed…

Microsoft loves Red Hat: The business implications

November 18th, 2015

As you may have heard, Microsoft recently announced its “historical” partnership with Red Hat, something that a number of analysts already claimed as a milestone for both companies but especially for…

Red Hat acquires Ansible

October 16th, 2015

Today Red Hat announced that it has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Ansible, provider of an IT automation tool popular especially within the developers’ community.
The acquisition is rumored…

Dell acquires EMC, owner of VMware and Pivotal

October 12th, 2015

Dell today announced that it signed a definitive agreement to acquire EMC Corporation for a total of $67 billion, making it the largest ever acquisition in the technology industry so…

Red Hat announces earnings for Q2 2015

October 2nd, 2015

Red Hat announced its financial results for the second quarter of fiscal year 2016.
Total revenue for the second quarter ended Augus 31, 2015 was $504 million, with an increase…

Citrix retires XenClient

September 21st, 2015

Citrix on its website announced that it started the End-of-Life process of Citrix XenClient Enterprise, the end of life date will be December 12, 2016.
XenClient consists of two technologies,…

Release: Altaro VM Backup V6

September 9th, 2015

Altaro Software, company specialized in backup for virtualized environments, specifically Microsoft Hyper-V, announced the release of Altaro VM Backup, previously known as Altaro Hyper-V Backup, rebranded to introduce VMware…

Release: CloudPhysics for vSphere

September 9th, 2015

CloudPhysics, provider of a SaaS performance and capacity analytics solution, announced to have released a new version of its SaaS offering allowing now VMware users to preempt and eliminate…

VMware announcements from its annual VMworld US conference

September 2nd, 2015

During its annual VMworld conference held between August 30 and September 3 in San Fransicso VMware made several announcements. During the keynote on Monday several data center related announcements and…

Release: VMware Workstation 12 Pro, Player 12, Fusion 8 and Fusion Pro 8

August 25th, 2015

VMware today released version 12 of its type-2 client hypervisor products for Microsoft Windows: Workstation Pro and Player and version 8 of its client hypervisor products for Mac OSX: Fusion….

 
Monthly Archive